Dear Respected Scholars
My question today is many Sikh people say main Sukhna mangi Gurdwara ja ke or main Manaat mangi si Guru ghar ja ke.
Guru Ji is ang sang, so what is the need for this?
Please share your thoughts on this.
SUKHNA & MANNAT
Share
I agree with the earlier answer;
Please allow me to add my two bits here:
This concept of SUKHNA is borrowed from other faiths. It is based on deities accepting bribes in exchange of giving gifts. Sikhs, ignorant of Gurbani message, treat the Guru Sahib and/or the ੴ the same way a bribable entity.
They forget the Gurbani verse:
ਕਰਮੀ ਕਰਮੀ ਹੋਇ ਵੀਚਾਰੁ ॥
ਸਚਾ ਆਪਿ ਸਚਾ ਦਰਬਾਰੁ ॥ (ਮ:੧, ਪੰ:੭)
Spirit of the message is: One received what one deserves based on their deeds. The ੴ (Eikko) THE ONE , is true and just.
In Sikhi, there is no room for favors in exchange for SUKHNA.
The truth is people do SUKHNA, MANNATAN because of ignorance. According to GURBANI our GURU, GOD IS SHABAD, BANI, GIAN, DIVINE WISDOM . Question is what would such GOD will give us. WINN TUD HORE JE MANGNA SIRR DUKHAN KAI DUKH. This mean only SUKHNA that will be fulfilled is for NAAM, WISDOM, KNOWLEDGE, GIAN that gives us inner peace, happiness and joy. Several years back I was in India. We visited one DERA. There were over 50 AKHAND PATHS going on. I asked GRANTHI who are these for. He said people SUKHNA SUKH and do these AKHAND PATHS. People are so ignorant if you try to explain that such SUKHNA like winning a court case will never be fulfilled they label you NASTIK. The only solution is GURMAT EDUCATION .
Thank you ????????